Tuesday, January 15, 2019

The Grievance Monster

Today I'm going to a grievance hearing in Manhattan. It's not my favorite thing to do, but I love taking the train in. It's a great luxury for me to sit and read for a while. I rarely get to do that these days. The substance of the grievance hearing, though, is not something I particularly look forward to.

This is because the people who decide, at Step Two at least, may as well be the principal. Honestly, step one is the principal, and the principal is the person with whom you have a disagreement. Hence, the grievance. Now principals, like a whole lot of people, tend to think what they did was right. Otherwise, I figure, why would they have done that thing? Even if you or I thought the principal did the worst thing in the world, it's entirely possible the principal thinks you or I did the worst thing in the world. That's likely why we're sitting with letters in our files saying we did the worst things in the world.

Now here's the thing--the principal doesn't make these decisions alone. He gets help in the form of DOE legal. These are a bunch of Bloomberg remnants who sit around Tweed all day and tell principals whatever they've done is fine. You want to write a letter in file for something that happened over three months ago? Go ahead. The Contract is just a series of suggestions. You're the principal, and therefore entitled to do Any Damn Thing You Please.

Therefore, there are a whole lot of hearings that ought not to be even happening. I've been to maybe ten over the past year. At Step Two, you meet with higher-ups. The hearing is run by a representative of the chancellor, who decides. You're represented by someone from UFT, and the Superintendent has a rep who argues against you. Do you see any possibility of bias here?

If you don't, you should. It appears to me that the chancellor's reps are entirely prejudiced against UFT members. If the Contract says the principal has three months to write something up, and he writes it up six months later, you get a letter saying "the event was not an occurrence" and the grievance is therefore rejected. In other words, the thing that happened did not, in fact, happen, so the time line doesn't apply. And you get that back with the signature of the current chancellor.

In fairness, I'm told it's a rubber stamp and the chancellor does not actually read this stuff. In a way, I don't blame him. In a more substantial way, though, I do. I would not want my name affixed to an assertion that preposterous, ever. That's just one ridiculous decision I got last year, but there have been others.

In fact, I've been at hearings where the officer asks us to leave the room. We stand outside the room and hear everything inside. The officer basically tells the principal he has no case. We get called back in, but three or four months later that very same officer rules for the principal. Thus far, I've seen nothing remotely approaching reason out of Gold Street.

Terrible as that is, it's not the end of the line. You have a chance with an arbitrator. An arbitrator, supposedly, is beholden neither to admin nor the union. Here's the problem, though---because the DOE is full of lying, morally bankrupt scoundrels, a whole lot of black and white cases get sent to arbitration. This means, if the arbitrators want to please UFT sometimes, and DOE
 sometimes, the gray issues may be decided in favor of DOE.

One year, I grieved because our principal, rather than give us programs for the next year, simply cut up current programs and gave them to everyone. This was ridiculous, but the arbitrator was fine with it. The Contract does not say we will get new programs with rooms the penultimate day of the year so the principal can redistribute old programs. Were that true, the language would not be in the contract at all.

So here's the problem--even if your arbitrator collects the $1400 per-diem, even if your arbitrator graduated law school, even if your arbitrator appears to be fluent in English, there's every possibility the arbitrator can be, you know, stupid. Now I've got a pretty low tolerance for stupid myself. It's particularly disturbing when it comes from adults whose jobs, on the surface at least, entail being not stupid.

But what can you do? I'm hopeful that some facets of the new contract can replace the grievance process, which takes forever. I'm still waiting on six or seven from last year to go to arbitration. The grievance process grinds slowly indeed. We need to find a better way to resolve differences than putting them before rigged hearings at Gold Street and arbitrators who may or may not understand English better than the newcomers I teach.

At least my students have an excuse.

Monday, January 14, 2019

When Guns Come to School

One day last week I forgot to bring a book and some copies I needed to class. During my first class, I was giving a test. I guess I was preoccupied with that and forgot to bring what I needed. I was able to call another teacher to watch the class for a moment while I went down to get my things.

Every now and then, we forget things. Once in a while I forget to bring my phone or my laptop. It's kind of remarkable to me that when I started teaching, I had neither. My laptop has become my most trusted and used tool. I have no idea how I ever did without it.

Last week, in nearby Babylon, someone left a gun lying around. I guess the person took it off in the bathroom and forgot to put it back on. The superintendent writes that the gun was not loaded, and that, I suppose, is to suggest it was less of a threat.

Personally, I'm not altogether impressed by that. First of all, if someone can forget an unloaded gun, someone can just as easily forget a loaded one. Also, who knows who might have picked it up? While this time it was someone who saw fit to return it, there's no guarantee that would happen next time.

Lest you think this is an isolated incident, it isn't. In Arkansas, an officer left a gun in another bathroom, and as the article says nothing about this firearm being unloaded, I'm going to assume it wasn't. How do you feel about elementary students wandering around and finding firearms in school? I'm not particularly comfortable with it.

Of course I think bringing firearms into schools is a terrible idea. I wouldn't feel any safer knowing that armed people were walking around where I worked. I wouldn't want my kid attending such a school either. For me, that would be far worse than my being there. You know who else finds it an unacceptable risk? Insurance companies. Evidently,  they see heightened risk, not the reduced risk DeVos, Trump, and their fellow troglodytes blather about.

Accidents happen. People make mistakes. Having deadly firearms around means said mistakes and accidents can be a whole lot worse. It's pretty pathetic that the NRA has bought off so many politicians. What's wrong with making it more difficult for lunatics to buy weapons? Why on earth do I have to buy insurance for my car, designed to get me to work, when people don't need to buy insurance for their AR-15s, designed to kill people?

I'm not sure how many more Americans will have to die before we apply the same common sense we saw displayed in Australia, where they managed to cut down on the sort of incidents we see occurring here. What do the NRA-purchased politicians say? They offer "thoughts and prayers." Let's move away from guns, keep them out of our schools, and use thoughts and prayers to build the wall for the orange Idiot-in-Chief.

Thursday, January 10, 2019

DOE Can't Walk and Chew Gum--I Volunteer to Do It for Them

I frequently wonder why, when UFT is flexible enough to allow the chancellor the Bronx Plan he so wants immediately, that the DOE can't grant teachers fewer observations immediately. I have been in meetings where I''ve heard that the system is broken. UFT thinks so. DOE thinks so. The observations are wasteful, they say. Some supervisors wait until the end of the year and just do them all in May, though I have no idea how.

Given that, it makes sense to determine that bunching them all up at the end, to use a word with which DOE is familiar, is ineffective. Now my understanding is that word represents the scourge of western civilization, and that therefore whatever it represents must be avoided at any and all costs. Yet we plod on, doing it this way, as though we've never done it any other way.

The rationale, they say, is that they've already designed Advance. You know, it's there, it's what it is, and any change would mean it would be something else. It would be, you know, different. Oddly, that's exactly the difference every working teacher would like to see. Not only that, but I'm personally acquainted with administrators who would dance and sing if the observation requirement were to be decreased immediately. Would you like to watch administrators dance and sing? You wouldn't have to if you didn't want to.

Anyway, to change a program you have to, you know, write stuff. Now I'm an English teacher, and I face a whole lot of teenagers each and every day. Few people understand better than I the aversion people have to writing stuff. Hell, I write every day, and some days I sit and wonder, "What the hell am I gonna write today?" It's not easy.

Here's the thing, though--if you're a teacher, you can't just say, "You know what? I just don't feel like writing stuff." After all, you have to write plans pretty much every day. You have to do all kinds of paperwork. You have to fill out forms. You have to think ahead. So imagine you're in charge of teachers. Ever hear of leading by example?

I doubt that's a popular concept over in Tweed. I can't imagine the educrats actually doing what we do. I imagine they sit around in Tweed all day planning where they'll go to lunch. There are a whole lot of places to eat downtown. You could go somewhere different each and every day. You could take long walks down there. I've been downtown a lot over the last few years and I love it. Of course, I don't go until after I've taught, usually, so I haven't got the same level of time the Tweedie birds do.

So how dare the United Federation of Teachers ask that they write new stuff? How dare we ask that they alter a program. Do you know how many hours they spent writing that crap, or paying other people to write the crap for them? Do you know how unpleasant that must've been? Clearly they were planning to get back into their offices for the rest of the year, and not think about doing anything new until the summer. After all, in the summer they're probably on vacation, and maybe they can play banjo players in Tennessee $15 an hour to do the work for them,.

If that's the case, why not pay them now? Banjo players don't really have busy seasons in the winter. Or in the summer, or ever. If they can't find a banjo player, they could hire me. I might charge a little more, but I could write a better program in one day. They could sit in their offices, go out to lunch, perform unnatural acts in their offices, or do whatever it is they do in Tweed. I don't even need to come in. I'll write it on my little Macbook and email it to them.

It's not hard to make a deal if neither party is Donald Trump. I wonder if Trump is running the DOE in his spare time.

Wednesday, January 09, 2019

Team Teaching and Its Discontents

The other day I heard about someone who wants to quit because of team teaching. You don't hear that every day. I mean, I get complaints about team teachers fairly regularly. This one's crazy. This one is awful. This one doesn't understand anything. Then you talk to the partners and likely as not, they say the same things about their counterparts.

Some people just don't get along. To assign such people to a veritable marriage is beyond idiotic, but inevitable in a system in which the standard is something like, "I need two volunteers. You, and you. Now you are team teachers." As chapter leader, I get sucked into the middle of these situations, and that's the very worst place to be. It's particularly inconvenient if your job happens to be representing both of the feuding parties.

I'll tell you a secret--I don't like everyone. I'm courteous to everyone, but I don't want to team teach with everyone. We complain that there's no training, and that's an absolutely valid point. But I've been to training, well before I ever co-taught, and what training I've seen is woefully inadequate. There's this model, where one person instructs and the other assists. There's that, where you take turns. There's some other, where you do something else. But hey, if  you hate me and everything I stand for, there's not gonna be any particularly great model.

This notwithstanding, I don't oppose team teaching. I'm sure I've written this before, but I had a great experience with a team teacher. She and I had very different personalities and inclinations. We had very different approaches to teaching. But I think we were good influences on one another. We got along well in front of the kids and I think that, in itself, made us good role models. She has endless patience while I have almost none whatsoever, but we found ways to work around that.

None of this, bad, good, or otherwise, would likely cause someone to want to quit teaching, Even if I'm in the worst pair-up on earth, I can look forward to June, If things are truly that awful, few administrators would be stupid enough to give it another year. Some would, but that's probably not why people quit.

The person I heard about was an ESL teacher, like me. Since the geniuses in Albany determined we were around not to teach English to people who, you know, don't know English we've had a pretty tough path. Now our job is to make students pass core subjects, important stuff like math and science. Who cares if a person has no knowledge of basic English structure as long as she's passed a test?

What this has entailed in schools all over the state has been ESL teachers standing around in classrooms while students learned about enzymes and hormones. Or the Civil War. Or Othello. You see, while newcomers may not understand this stuff at all, having an ESL professional in the room makes that okay. While the subject teacher shows the native English speakers what's important, the ESL teacher is supposed to magically provide the English component. There's no extra time to do it, so magic is the prime methodology.

And if you can't do magic, you can go screw yourself. Oh, and when you get a Danielson observation, it's your fault the kid who's been here six weeks can't characterize Atticus Finch.

Imagine you're in five classes like that with five different teachers. I know a high school teacher in that situation, and he's one of many. Imagine you're an elementary school teacher with nine different classes, in which you have no input. I know someone like that too. You are not really a teacher. You're a body, placed somewhere to do a job that is impossible.

You stand there and wonder why you took all those courses. You wonder why you worked to be a teacher and you aren't one. These feelings eat at you, and as time goes on, they expand. They multiply. You wanted to be a teacher, but you're no one.

This is no way to feel good about yourself. Meanwhile, the ELLs are learning nothing. They're failing. They're discouraged. What are administrators to do? Probably blame the teachers. But even if they don't, it's pretty darn depressing to know you're being paid for a position that essentially serves no purpose.

I've been pretty vocal about the degradation of our profession and the innocent children who are going down with us. But I'm fortunate in that I happen to have multiple certifications and thus do not absolutely have to co-teach. Many of my colleagues, and many of their students are not remotely so fortunate.

That is nothing short of a disgrace. We're wasting the time of children and teachers. And this teacher isn't the first I've heard who's contemplating a career change over this nonsense. We're wasting desperately needed teachers as well. In the era of Donald Trump, NY States ELLs need all the support we can give them. Instead, they have the myopic NY State Regents. If they knew nothing about language acquisition, it would represent an improvement.

Monday, January 07, 2019

UFT Executive Board January 7, 2018--We Support LA Teachers and Discuss Election

Secretary Howard Schoor welcomes us..

Speakers—

Betty Godfried—retired Adult ed. CL—After 7 years, Rose Marie Mills has been removed (applause) and is being reassigned. Third time an unsuitable admin has been dismissed in recent years. Only teachers or paras are discontinued. Admin is moved around. Rank and file made these things happen. Current fight was in service and retired members who were victimized.

Ended illegal test procedures, articles published, met with reps, spoke here. Documented activities, will prepare packet. Thanks Schoor for giving it to Mills, thanks Mulgrew for meeting, would’ve liked more support. Carmen Alvarez also supportive. Still long way to go, issues need to be resolved. New superintendent may need guidance. Union may need to negotiate. Thanks teachers for all the work they did, thanks for applause, thanks for those who do listen, says coming here has made a difference.

This ten minute mike one of last bastions of true union democracy. Giving voice to voiceless is doing something good.

David Price—CL Bard HS Queens—Teachers at school want to know what UFT will do in solidarity with UTLA. Happy to see resolution in favor. Concerned that DA is after the 10th. Proposed resolved.

Schoor—Only members may propose resolutions.

Price—Urges members to add resolved that UFT invite UTLA leaders to speak before elected bodies, and that we publicize UTLA campaigns. Has members who want to donate to strike fund, would rather contribute to that than COPE. We are in solid position to show strength.

Schoor—At last meeting I called on non-member of Exec. Board. We need to know who people are who come in so we are now requiring sign-ins. We welcome all members and retired members. We need to know why people are here if they are not members.

Minutes—approved

President’s report—Michael Mulgrew—Wishes us happy new year. Had Bronx plan rollout. Wants to thank staff. Was great event, with over 400 people. Idea of us saying we have challenged schools that will come up with their own plan is better, supported by UFT and DOE. Around country people just get rid of people. We have a better idea. Being part of contract says a lot about our values.

APPR number one issue in state negotiations. You would think 8301, the bill we wanted, since it was passed by Assembly, since Governor said he would sign it, you would assume it would be easy. There is a bit of a budget problem. State has 2 billion shortfall. Next year there will be major drop. We want state money for community learning to go to community learning. We want to put in safeguards. We want more money dispersed based on need. Governor argues for this, but we could argue he doesn’t do it. It’s now part of conversation.

Will probably be strike in LA. We’ll send things out to membership. We should wear red for them. We will send it out and move forward.

We will have fun this year, and thank you for being here.

LeRoy Barr—We will hopefully pass resolution on LA strike. Town Hall meeting on public advocate coming. 1/19 women’s march UFT will hold breakfast forum. We will send invite with address. Next Exec. Board 1/28, date needs to change. Next DA 1/16.

Schoor—Conflict on 1/28. Have two alternatives. 1/14, one week from today, or 1/22, day after MLK day. Suggests 22nd.

Shelvy Abrams—Move to have meeting on 22nd. Seconded.

Passed

Questions

Arthur Goldstein—I have two questions today. My first is recurring. Every teacher I know wants fewer observations. Every administrator I know, at least the ones who are not insane, wants fewer observations. Since the UFT and DOE seem to agree that our current system is broken and pointless, why can’t we agree to less of it now that we all agree?

A fair compromise, if we need one, would be to agree to one more observation for the second half, so as to get a fair view of what we did all year.

Secondly, I was shocked to read the DOE has something called a charter school space request form. I understand that Eva Moskowitz wants space. While I’d like as much space as possible between Eva and myself, and my students, I’m hard pressed to understand why her needs are more important than those of my sorely overcrowded school.

I appreciate the support we’ve gotten from leadership, and I appreciate that in a few years we will have more space. But we are a real school. Unlike Eva, I don’t just hire my kid in college to teach AP courses. Unlike Eva, UFT schools don’t grab just anyone and pay them minimum wage to teach children. Unlike Eva, if I were to make a kid pee his pants in class, I’d be up on charges.

If there is a charter school space request form to a board full of charter advocates, why don’t we press for one for real schools, with real training, real requirements, real jobs, and real teachers, like the one my students attend? Could we have a public school space request form to a board full of public school advocates? I’m a public school advocate and I volunteer for the board.

Schoor—will bring this up to chancellor and report back. Will ask Evelyn to speak to it.

Evelyn de Jesus—We are meeting internally. I know Michael spoke about contract. We are meeting internally, will have members on it. We cannot do it mid-year. Right now, this is not possible. We want to make sure that it rolls how we need. We will take it back to the committee, but it’s not going to happen as fast as you like.

Mike Schirtzer—Out of all new members that joined DOE, how many have joined? We are hearing that there is a shortage of special ed. teachers and that is causing compliance issues. Are there stats on that? Is DOE doing anything?

Schoor—We had 3000 agency feel payers in September. There are now fewer than 300 who have not signed. We signed up most of new people. We did outreach. Some people signed multiple cards, but only take dues once.

Mary Jo Jenice—Shortage is across the board. You can only be appointed under one license, so some are hard to detect.

Mike Sill—Of course we know there are issues. We have some people in excess, but very few. License is mostly absorbed every year. Of course this causes issues.

Kate Martin Bridge—In reference to compliance, curious about how registration happens. In small school, we’re projected to have 343 students, as always, but we get 380. Principal feels she can’t hire teachers she needs. You get OTC and you’re out of compliance. Why does DOE do this if it happens year after year?

Janella Hinds—We know office of enrollment makes decisions about which students go to which schools. We know some schools are left out. Some schools get very high percentages of SIFE students, newcomers, coming from incarceration. We are engaging with new admin about what this should look like.

Jonathan Halabi—When will we find out which schools will be included in Bronx plan?

Rich Mantel—115 schools showed up, 127 invited. We will see who applies and let you know.

Halabi—Tuition reimbursement for nurses has been changed. Are we doing anything about this?

Schoor—We will check. Send me email. We will fix if we are entitled.

Halabi—Contract implementation—Regents and program committees—Are they being formed?

Hinds—Will be formed after February 14.

Halabi—Having hard time understanding why my friend isn’t sitting with me today. Would like those I invite here to sit with me.

Schoor—You don’t want a visitor’s section?

Halabi—I would like people to sit with me.

Schoor—We will discuss this. We have to make sure we have security here.

KJ Ahluawala—One of our members is seriously ill. What is rationale for 2 to 1?

Schoor—No contractual agreement Board decided this. Has never come up in negotiations.

Ellen Fpx—guest—Interested party in new arrangement. I am a 12 year CL, 20 year delegate, 8 year Exec. Board member, 50 year UFT member. Shocked when we were asked to produce credentials. Listened very carefully. Seems there should be a better way to distinguish between outside forces and UFT members. Seems extremely disrespectful and strange. Respectfully request that UFT members can go back to do what they’ve always been doing. Press and others can use visitors section.

Schoor—Thank you. We will take that under consideration.

Report from districts—Rashad Brown—I gave flyer about Pride committee workshop—pathways to parenthood. Will be attorneys to talk about ways to have a child, including non traditional 1/26 4-6

Paul Egan—God exists and is an Eagles fan. Was great weekend. Chelsea won third round 2-0. Eagles won 16-15.

Mayor announced Public Advocate race 2/26. 23 people in race. Mark Viverito first one in, got first place on ballot. Third forum Brooklyn Thursday. Mulgrew will moderate. Will be panel. Filings finished 1/11. We can have conversation at DA on 16th.

Special order of business—Paul Egan—NY State is an embarrassment in terms of how elections are conducted. NC was sued for voter suppression, and Secretary of State used NY voting rules as defense for why there was not voter suppression in NC. That is an embarrassment. We are light years behind in voting and access. We have a number of ideas to open up and expand voting rights, early voting, automatic registration.

We have 2 million unregistered. Could be done via tax return, ID, driver license. Flexibility to change party should not be over a year in advance. Want permanent restoration of voting rights written in law, consolidation of party primaries. Same day registration, well-designed ballots. We want to encourage voting and make it easier. Polls open at different hours statewide, we should change that. We want ranking rather than runoffs. Would save money and make sure there is only one election.

Mike Schirtzer—Amendment—First whereas says malfunction—would like to add, “Working voting machines.” as request. Out of four where I was, three didn’t work.

Add resolved—“That the UFT will call on the NYC Board of Elections to implement these reforms.”

Paul Egan—Suggests we add NYC and NY State Board of Elections.

Passes as amended

LeRoy Barr—Rising to report you have two documents. Report that there were proposals.

All caucuses will get ads regardless of whether they have enough candidates to form a slate.
2. Caucuses may submit different material if they wish in two issues.
3. Camera ready material due on 2/5 and 3/5.

Second packet—would need to modify and add second date.

There is also candidate statement piece, and nominating petitions.

Arthur Goldstein—If Mike Schirtzer and I decide that we want to run as a caucus, can we get 2 pages in the NY teacher for Schirtzer Goldstein caucus--is that what I'm hearing?

Barr—Those who don’t meet requirement want to have representation in NY Teacher. If you are saying you have two, will assume that is correct.

Washington Sanchez—In essence, what Arthur said is correct. The committee did not want to prevent this. We didn’t think that would happen. Committee reserved right to come back and revisit the issue. Was lengthy discussion, many different views. Because of Janus we did not want anyone to feel slighted.

Michael Shulman—Basically, what LeRoy laid out was essence of discussion. Was not unanimous. Some raised same concern Arthur did. Decision was any caucus would be allowed two pages. We will follow the practice of allowing space. Independents were given space in NY teacher. Perhaps individuals will get space allotted in line with what has taken place in past.

Schoor—Any other comments?

Passes

LeRoy Barr—Next item is resolution in support of striking LA teachers. Our brothers and sisters are getting ready to strike. Want to make it clear we are in solidarity. Ask that we wear red on Thursday in solidarity. That would include telling them what’s going on. We can do that. We have at least two AFT VPs here. We are in contact with them. Our President will be in contact with what they specifically need. These people will decide. Wouldn’t be the best thing to hamstring them. Asking you support resolution before you.

Arthur Goldstein—amendment—add--Resolved—UFT will immediately publicize progress of the UTLA contract campaign to rank and file.

Resolved—UFT invite UTLA leaders to speak before January DA.

Resolved—UFT donate to UTLA strike fund.

Jonathan Halabi—Rises in support of original motion. This country had very strong union movement. Has been crippled. Public sector unions, particularly teacher unions are bulwark for us. Would hope maker of original motion and amendment can find common ground. Speaker already spoke to publicizing. Perhaps we could get video message. Not sure about donation, but sends important message. More we do publicly, the more we say that we take this very seriously. Hope we can bridge gap.

Evelyn de Jesus—I’m torn. Agree with Jonathan. Want to go to original motion. We have three AFT presidents. Don’t wish to tie their hands. We wish to speak to them. These amendments are not possible, but we may do them later on. Support original motion.

Rashad Brown—Calls question.

Debate closed.

Amendments fail.

Original motion passes. We are adjourned. 7:24.

Sunday, January 06, 2019

Donors Choose to Keep Us Broke

The existence of Donors Choose is a blight on the landscape, a national disgrace. This is an organization that exists solely so we, teachers, can beg for things we need in our classrooms. My students need a video camera. My students need seats. We need a microscope for our science class.

It is simply unconscionable that we don't provide classrooms with these things as a matter of course. How can we claim to be providing an adequate education when kids don't have the necessities? Is the solution to send teachers out to ask donors to help? I'd argue it isn't, and that this is a fundamental shortcoming of our society, like lack of health care.

This is on par with "separate but equal." Why is it that Ms. A. has adequate seating while Ms. B. does not? Is Ms. B. a bad teacher because she didn't go out on Donors Choose and ask for financial help? Should signing up to get people to support fundamental classroom needs be a requirement for teachers? And if it is, are teachers who draw more money more highly effective?

Under that scenario, I'm a truly terrible teacher. I'm in half a room, and no matter how I arrange the seats it will remain inadequate. Should I contact Donors Choose and demand a fund to demolish our school building and redo it so as to accommodate the number of students who actually attend? I need, say, ten million dollars. 100 million dollars. I don't even know how much I need.

If you're wondering why red states are up in arms and on strike, look no further. If you're wondering why LA is about to strike, ask yourself why teachers need to ask strangers to support their work. It's the job of the community to support education. That means not only paying teachers a fair salary, but also providing adequate space and facilities. Red states have turned their collective backs on education, bleeding schools and teachers dry for revenue. They've gone past the breaking point and just can't help themselves.

You could argue that Donors Choose is just a philanthropic organization looking to set things straight. You could argue that their mission is one of charity, or helping teachers to do what they need to, since the government has abandoned us. Were that the case, I'd argue that it behooved Donors Choose to take an activist stance against the abandonment of public education. They ought to be devoting their resources to not only buying chairs for Ms. A's class, but also ensuring that Ms. B. had them too. In short, they ought to be working to ensure their existence not be perpetually necessary.

Of course, you could also argue that a charitable organization ought not to be political. You could argue that no, the idea is to help those who need it and not get in the middle of political disagreements. You could say the best position for an organization like Donors Choose would be political neutrality. In fact, it would be hard to argue with you if you said that.

Of course, the problem is that Donors Choose is not politically neutral. When the execrable film Waiting for Superman came out, Donors Choose promoted it. In fact, it offered moviegoers a $15 credit for seeing the anti-union, anti-public school propaganda piece. In fact, right now you can agree to get updates from Waiting for Superman, and Donors Choose will give you $15.

Here's what Diane Ravitch said about Waiting for Superman and another pro-charter film in her piece, The Myth of Charter Schools:

The message of these films has become alarmingly familiar: American public education is a failed enterprise. The problem is not money. Public schools already spend too much. Test scores are low because there are so many bad teachers, whose jobs are protected by powerful unions. Students drop out because the schools fail them, but they could accomplish practically anything if they were saved from bad teachers.

It's all our fault. There's no inequity. There's no poverty. There's no lack of opportunity or health care. The sole reason students suffer is bad teachers, along with their crooked unions who exist only to enable them. It's ironic, to say the least, that an organization whose existence depends upon inadequate school funding would propagate such a message. It's particularly ironic that they'd embrace a message that the problem is not money when their very existence hinges upon providing needed money.

Nonetheless, that's the message they endorse. If I needed to raise money, I'd find some other way to do it. I won't participate in an organization that promotes nonsensical reformy propaganda. Let Betsy DeVos and her wealthy BFFs get more wealthy some other way.

Saturday, January 05, 2019

Killer Lettuce

Could you ever have imagined such a thing? Here it is, America 2019, and just a few short months ago no one could eat salad. In some circles, that might be cause for celebration. After all, who wants to eat a salad when you could just as easily grab a pepperoni pizza, or fried chicken, or any number of things that will make you feel like, yes, I deserve this.

On the other hand, we're right in the middle of an obesity epidemic, caused at least partially by our incredibly poor eating habits. I certainly understand why people don't want to eat salad. I'm thinking salad for lunch today, and it makes me a little sad. But hey, we all have to make sacrifices here and there.

There were very few things I liked about Michael Bloomberg's tenure as mayor, but I'll tell you what they both are:

1. He pushed unconventional seating and allowed us to place seats in arrangements other than rows.

2. He made all the city lunch use whole grains instead of white bread.

That's it, actually. I can't think of anything else he did to improve anything, and almost every working teacher and in service student is still feeling the effects of his seemingly endless tenure. I was surprised he didn't find a way to buy himself a fourth term and inflict yet another charm offensive upon us. (Of course, now he's looking at buying the White House, perish forbid.)

I lost a bunch of weight maybe eleven years ago. Then I got cancer and decided, the hell with it, I'll eat what I want. I did that for around ten years until my doctor told me I was borderline diabetic. I decided that was a line I didn't want to cross and started eating a lot more carefully. Hey, I ate whatever I wanted for ten years. I had a good run. Now I'm down to a better weight, but it's really hard to stay there.

It's actually easier when I'm working. One reason is, that unlike most high schools, our school has a teacher cafeteria. While Bloomberg was focused on nutrition in school cafeterias, his contempt for us was so intense that he closed every teacher cafe that wasn't making money. As chapter leader, I sent an email to staff saying if our cafe didn't improve its numbers, we'd lose it. A lot of us started patronizing it more after that. To Bloomberg, nutrition was key, but not for public school teachers. He hated us with a vengeance, and I certainly hope that's made clear to primary voters if he runs.

Even if you're fortunate enough to have a cafe, once the killer lettuce thing happened, you weren't getting salad. In our cafe, you can buy a small chef's salad, or you can choose tuna fish in a cup with salad and a vegetable on the side. That's better for you than the frozen (perhaps thawed) chicken and fish patties covered with canned sauces or processed cheeses. It's better for you than frozen pizza, burritos filled with chicken nuggets and Lord only knows what else.

Last week there was no tuna, and no salad. The salad made an appearance yesterday, but who knows how long that will last? The American food business is about as clean as American politics, and we could easily have another killer lettuce scare.

It's a disgrace that Bloomberg closed teacher cafeterias. We need a place to sit and talk, we need a place to unwind, and it's shortsighted and cruel to deny it over a few sheckels in a city that's got three billion dollars to give Jeff Bezos. The craze for inquiry teams is short-sighted and pointless, and judging principals by them is idiotic. We are adults. We know when to reach out for help and advice. Forcing it upon us just makes us hate it.

Mayor Bill de Blasio continues the Bloomberg policy of packing schools to the gills, with no regard whatsoever for potential ill effects.  You'd think one of his highly paid, highly educated assistants might say, "Hey, you know what? Maybe if we treated teachers with respect, they'd do a better job."

No such luck. Healthy options? You have to show up on the right day. A place to eat, to informally meet and discuss what you do every day? You don't need that. We're busy finding space for Moskowitz Academies.

Thursday, January 03, 2019

NYC Has a Charter School Space Request Form. Public Schools? You're on Your Own.

I'm absolutely flabbergasted reading Leonie Haimson's account of an office called "District Planning." I mean, I'm pro-district and pro-planning, so at first blush, it seems like a good idea. But like much of Bill de Blasio's education administration, it appears to be a leftover from Bloomberg and Klein. Changing its name does not appear to have much altered its fundamental mission.

Of course I know well that they don't do diddly squat for those of us who are egregiously overcrowded. Leonie discusses what it takes to run this group:

Their main qualifications for this job seemed to be able to portray no emotion during contentious and emotional public hearings, when teachers, students and parents begged them not to close their schools or force them into smaller spaces because of co-locations. 

I recall John White at the contentious Jamaica closing hearings, utterly indifferent to what teachers, students, politicians, residents and clergy had to say. I can't recall anyone saying anything other than reasons not to close the school, but White had a job to do, ignored absolutely everyone in the hall, and declared his intention to close it anyway based on flawed statistics. Mayoral control is all about sidestepping the interests of community, and it worked exactly the way Bloomberg wanted it to. Right after John White closed Jamaica High School, he crawled back into his coffin until he got a more prestigious gig in New Orleans.

Of course it's disappointing to see this office populated by a charter-friendly group of reformies, and even more disappointing de Blasio didn't see fit to clean house and start from scratch. I worked for him, contributed to him, and attended his inauguration thinking this was a new day for us. While it's true he doesn't close down schools at the same rate Bloomberg did, it's still happening.

What really hit home with me, though, was this:

“State Education Law provides certain new and expanding charter schools with access to facilities.  Charter schools requesting space in a DOE facility, must fill out the Charter School Space Request Form.” 

What? There's actually a request form for charter schools that need space? Here's why this is shocking to me--there's no such form for public schools that need space. From my vantage point, teaching 34 kids in half a room, that's unconscionable. I'm not sure whether or not my school is at its highest enrollment ever, but I do know that I've never seen it so overcrowded before.

We're actually set to get some relief in the form of an annex, but that's years in the future. For now, I have no office space as chapter leader and our principal has closed his conference room to be used as a classroom. We have several poorly ventilated windowless former bookrooms masquerading as classrooms. Don't get me started on the trailers, but truth be told I'd rather be in a trailer than half a classroom. That's why I requested the trailers for a dozen years or more.

The only reason we're set to get relief is because I was elected to UFT Executive Board and brought it up the very first time I spoke there. Otherwise we'd probably have been offered nothing, which was and is the DOE's standing approach to overcrowding--do nothing and hope no one complains too loudly. I was once able to turn it around by working with a whole lot of people, getting us all over the press, but for various reasons, our agreement with the city collapsed.

It's an absolute outrage that charters are able to request space and we are not. City policy is that that district kids can attend district schools. That's fine, except the city can't be bothered to make sure we have any place to put these kids. That Eva Moskowitz gets priority over Francis Lewis High School is an abomination, and having a city agency that doesn't give a golly gosh darn about public school students is well beyond unacceptable.

It's time for Mayor de Blasio to take a stand in favor of the overwhelming majority of children and parents in New York City.

Where the hell is that public school space request form, Mr. Mayor?

Wednesday, January 02, 2019

Bigger Than Beto, Biden or Bernie

There's a whole lot of back and forth online about how it's sacrosanct to criticize Beto O'Rourke. Though Beto himself says he isn't running for President in 2020, he's been drafted by a whole lot of people who say he reminds them of Obama. Certainly he's a great speaker, and he's appealing to a whole lot of people. Too bad more of them aren't in Texas, or we wouldn't have Ted Cruz to kick around anymore.

A lot of people, including some Facebook friends of mine, see this as prime opportunity to stereotype progressives. It's our fault that Trump's President, evidently. Too many of us failed to vote for Hillary. Worse, a lot of people will vote for Jill Stein in 2020, and hand Trump the election once again. For the record, I voted for Hillary against Donald Trump, though I found her beyond unsatisfactory. Hillary said we would never, ever get universal health care, and that free college would benefit Donald Trump's kids, as though he'd send them to community colleges.

I understand Texas is different from the rest of the United States, and that you have to take different positions to be electable there. But there's nothing wrong with reporting facts, even if they're about Beto. I've seen a gaggle of articles saying that this was some sort of conspiracy from Bernie, or Bernie Bros, or whatever term they're using to stereotype progressives this week.

Here's something that David Sirota, crucified by a lot of non-progressive benefits for pointing out how much oil money Beto took, has not been mentioning--Beto's wife is not only a billionaire heiress, but also runs a charter school. Now again, this is Texas. Union's not a big thing down there. It's a little more important to me, to us, and to New York. Union's also kind of pivotal in America, if we want our children to have a shot at middle class. I haven't necessarily ruled out Beto, but I'd need to have a whole lot more detail on his national positions, in the unlikely event he were to run.

I keep recalling Joe Biden sitting by and watching Anita Hill get crucified up there. I don't recall his raising a peep when Arne Duncan declared Katrina to be the best thing to happen to NOLA education. His credentials are less than sterling.

Others are far worse. Cory Booker is a definite no for me. I don't care who he runs against. His education positions are horrendous, in line with Chris Christie, Betsy DeVos, and every hedge fund operator who hates us and everything we stand for. I can't cast a positive vote for anyone who works to dismantle public education, and if Democrats want to retake the presidency, they're gonna need a more effective battle cry than, "not Donald Trump."

Michael Bloomberg is tossing his billions around again, offering to take another hundred mil from his pocket change and buy himself the White House. Bloomberg called an effort to repeal term limits, twice affirmed by city voters, "disgusting," but went and bought himself a one-time exception. For Bloomberg, breaking the rules is disgusting unless he himself chooses to do it, in which case it's fine. This is the same kind of thinking we get from the current occupant of the White House.

We don't need another self-important billionaire making decisions for us. Bloomberg is a whole lot smarter than Trump, and therefore a whole lot more dangerous. Rudy Giuliani probably had wet dreams about mayoral control in NYC, but could never make it happen. Rudy was always suing everyone over perceived slights like not being able to bring his mistress into the home he shared with his wife and young children. Bloomberg is more focused and gets things done. Given he has no regard for the will of the people, that's pretty scary for me.

If the Democrats want to win, they aren't going to be able to just prop someone up who stands for little or nothing. 70% of Americans support Medicare for All, including 52% of Republicans. A majority of Americans would like to see free college tuition. Of course, American wants higher wages, and I'm not sure how long we can be fooled by trillion dollar, budget-busting bonanzas for those who least need it.

We're gonna need a Democrat who really stands with working people this time, not just anybody. The threat of another Trump term, or even another GOP term, is unacceptable. It's not enough, in America, to just get more votes than your opponent. We need to win the next race, and we need to make it worth winning.

The problem with a lot of Democrats is they toss out 1972, and say be careful, you don't want to repeat that. Actually, union was stronger, middle class was more vibrant, and despite all the turmoil, working people were not quite so up against it in 1972. Furthermore, George McGovern was absolutely right about Vietnam, and history proves it. He wasn't "radical." He was 100% correct.

It's time to replace that outdated paradigm with 2016. We certainly don't want to repeat that. If we can't learn from 2016, we deserve to lose.

Tuesday, January 01, 2019

Happy New Year to All!

I wish you a happy, healthy, and prosperous New Year. I hope we move forward, and push our enemies just a little closer to the primordial ooze to which they belong. I'm sharing Woody Guthrie's New Year's Resolutions, which never seem to go out of style.

Let's see if we can keep up with Woody this year.


Sunday, December 30, 2018

I'm Here

That was the response, by one of my colleagues, when I asked, "How are you?" That makes me sad. She's not the only one, though. Sometimes, I get responses like, "Living the dream." This is even more depressing, because you're not only saying things suck, but you're ridiculing the possibility they may not. A few weeks ago, someone handed me a pamphlet when I was entering the DA. I asked, "How are you?" and the guy said, "I'm alive." "That's a low bar," I said.

We really have to take a look at that. I don't know exactly what's wrong with me, but I'm generally unable to see things like that. I mean, Donald Trump is the frigging President of the United States, and it's hard for me to think of anything more depressing than that. The day I found out, I dressed in black head to toe and forgot to go to the Delegate Assembly. I couldn't focus at all.

Now I'm excited about dumping him, sending him home, to prison,or whatever. I'm glad to see people like Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez alive and speaking truth to mealy-mouthed moderation. I'm thrilled the GOP hacks hate her so much, and go out of their way to ridicule her for her radical ideas, like health care for all, a living wage for Americans, and affordable college.

Things are tougher here in NYC. Sometimes I know exactly why people give me answers like those. Something happened, something didn't happen, something may or may not happen, and people take things to heart. Other times it's more disturbing. For me, there are few things so upsetting as having a teacher 30 years younger than I am tell me how lucky I am because I can retire. I think how lucky they are to be 30 years younger than I am. I wonder, though, whether I felt the same way 30 years ago.

It's hard to bring good news to working teachers. It's hard to inspire or rekindle hope. My building is generally okay, since two of the worst administrators I've ever encountered have moved on to torture people elsewhere. Yet all over the city there are lunatics in charge of working people, frequently because they've moved up. This teaching job is so hard that they couldn't wait to get out of the classroom, and now their subordinates hate them just as much as their students ever did. You can't win. You go to another place, but if your problem is yourself, it just tags along for the ride.

We have a new feature in the contract designed to target abusive and insane administrators, but it hasn't been tested yet. I certainly hope it proves effective. I think that would lessen the unsatisfactory responses to, "How are you?" But only time will tell. A lot of us are frightened to act, and that's an issue too.  I used to be like that. I used to worry that people would find out who wrote this blog. Now I don't care.

Maybe it's because I have enough time in that if someone were to come after me, the very worst thing to happen would be getting forced into retirement. I don't know. I just don't ever remember being so down that I'd say, "I'm here," when asked how I was.

I'm cheered by fewer observations. I know that isn't enough. In a country where teachers are perpetual scapegoats, nothing will ever be enough. It's kind of on us to stand up to this. I'm up for it, but I understand a lot of people are not. Some teachers feel this is a profession where you get to keep your head down and be quiet. I don't understand exactly how you interact with large groups of kids like that. I can't do it.

But I want us to be better than here. We need to tell our students we are more than here. We need to tell our country we are more than here. We need to not only be here. We need to be vocal and active. We need to stand up and defend our profession, and work to make it better. It's on us to make a better world for our children and students.

We start by getting our own house in order. That's not remotely easy. But it's essential.

Saturday, December 29, 2018

Arne Duncan--Yet Another Disaster for Puerto Rico

I'm friends with several people born in Puerto Rico, and the stories they tell will break your heart. Despite Donald Trump gamely tossing paper towels at people, the island has still not fully recovered from Hurricane Maria. Even before the hurricane, Puerto Rico was afflicted with vulture capitalists intent on draining its last drop of blood, enriching themselves while leaving the island barren of a middle class.

Then I see on Twitter that Arne Duncan is visiting. This could not bode well for the people of Puerto Rico, I thought.





It's true. Arne Duncan, the very person who said, in front of God and everybody that Hurricane Katrina was the best thing to happen to NOLA education, is working his magic in Puerto Rico. I don't think New Orleans, having experienced it,  is much amused. First of all, aside from the deaths, the injuries, and the massive loss of population, the schools do not seem to have improved. The only benefit has been for Arne's BFFs in the charter industry, people who see fit to monetize our children.

Puerto Rico, in fact, is facing the very same pressures New Orleans was. Charter schools were illegal in Puerto Rico until the hurricane presented an opportunity to privatize. Arne hasn't specifically tweeted on that, as far as I know, but he's still pushing his book, as well as the outlandish notion that he knows something about education. People are speaking out.



Peter Greene has a great piece in Forbes about how Arne keeps peddling his nonsense. Duncan is completely out of touch with what those of us who serve America's children see each and every day.

Duncan is also fond of the notion that class size doesn't matter as much as teacher quality, as if teacher quality isn't affected by class size. A paragraph later Duncan reasserts the importance of the "building meaningful relationships" with students, but he has never seemed to consider how much harder that is to do in a classroom full of thirty or forty or fifty students.

If you're a teacher, you're likely judged and rated by one form or another of junk science. Despite the fact that there's no scientific evidence to establish student test scores as a criteria for how well teachers do their jobs, his "Race to the Top" pushed not only that nonsense, but also non-unionized charter schools all over the country.  Now Puerto Rico, in addition to its other very real woes, has to contend with this nonsense as well.

Arne Duncan can tour the country blabbering about his book, but the fact is that the charter school movement is inherently an anti-union movement, and therefore of very dubious benefit to working people. This includes not only adults, but also our children. They will need to grow up to a world with fewer union jobs and fewer pathways to middle class.

If you're in Puerto Rico, and some tall white guy approaches you, even if he offers to play basketball, be very wary. Ask him if he's Arne Duncan. If he is, run, walk, drive or swim away as fast as you can. Though he may smile, though appear otherwise, he's no friend of yours. Also, if you should inadvertenly touch him, be sure to wash your whole body with Brillo pad. You don't know where he's been.

Thursday, December 27, 2018

A Modest Proposal--Wall for All--Trump Gives Universal Healthcare and We Give Him Wall Money

Poor Donald Trump. He sits in the White House, all alone, bitching about how those awful Democrats won't give him his precious wall. And he's magnanimous about it. He says they can call it a wall, a fence, or whatever he wants. Still, that awful Nancy Pelosi not only musters the unmitigated gall to be a woman, one of those people who bleeds from their eyes, from their whatevers, but also to tell him he's not getting the wall. How dare she?

As if that's not enough, he finally mustered the courage to go overseas and visit the troops, and what happens? Instead of writing about how brave and wonderful he is, the Fake News is pointing out that the military did not, in fact, get a 10% raise, and it wasn't the first raise in ten years either. Not only that, but they're saying he also revealed covert Navy Seal deployment. That's the thanks you get for finally giving in to all the haters saying Presidents do these things on Christmas.

Anyway, I've figured out a solution for not only the President, but also the country. It's time to put these times behind us. Sure, the President says the shutdown is okay because it's mostly Democrats not getting paid, Still, don't Democrats vote? I mean, what if the Democrats wake up and run someone who advocates universal health care, a living wage, and affordable college, things most Americans support? Everyone knows that Trump and the Republicans were full of crap when they said they had something better than Obamacare. So let's work together.

You take your 5 billion, build whatever wall that builds, and then you, Ann Coulter, and Fox and Friends can go and party like it's 1500 AD, or ancient China, or whenever and wherever walls were last effective. All we want in exchange is Medicare for All. And hey, if Medicare is so crappy, people will flock to buy private insurance instead. You see how that works? It's a WIN-WIN.

After all, everyone knows Trump prides himself on being a great deal maker. In fact, he even had someone ghost write a book called The Art of the Deal, which makes him pretty much a self-declared authority on the subject.  So instead of having a bunch of snotty bloggers and Fake News reporters call you a liar, simply because you lie all the time, why not solve a real problem for once?

All we want is Medicare for every American. And look, you can make it voluntary. If you don't want it, you don't have to take it. After all, there's that letter saying you're the healthiest individual ever to take the presidency. Now you can prove it by declining insurance, and you can eat all the KFC you like.

You see how everyone makes out here? You get your wall. No more Americans need to go bankrupt because of catastrophic medical emergency. No more Americans die needlessly for lack of health care. And of course, since you don't support that, you can let Democrats take credit. You will have yourself a wall. You can call it beautiful. You can please Ann Coulter and Fox and Friends, and since their opinions appear to be the only ones you care about, you can sit in front of your big screen all day and have them praise you endlessly.

No charge for this solution, Mr. President. We teachers solve problems all the time.

Tuesday, December 25, 2018

Merry Christmas to All

I wish you a joyous holiday. I'm in between various family visits. More inclined to go to ones that allow me to bring my dog, but don't tell anyone. Leaving you with my favorite Christmas song. Well, it's not really a Christmas song, but it's one of my favorites, and it should be a Christmas song. That's Rhonda Vincent singing, and that's the best band she ever had, particularly the fiddler, a very young Michael Cleveland.


Monday, December 24, 2018

On Walls and Seating Charts

On this Christmas Eve I'm thinking about my students and wondering if they're a microcosm of society. I'm focused particularly on my beginning class, and seeing them as reflective of much larger problems. My job, ostensibly, is to either inspire, persuade, or force kids to learn English. Of course I hope for the first or second options, and they work a whole lot better than the third, but whatever port in a storm.

In the half classroom I have this year, there are tables of four. These tables kind of force the kids into groups whether they like it or not. I'm not really sure whether or not that makes me Danielson-ready, because who really understands the factors that go into that? First there's that complicated rubric, which you may or may not understand, and then there's the supervisor, who also may or may not understand the rubric. In addition, the supervisor may or may not be delusional, overtly hostile, or be in need of proving something. So many factors to consider.

If I leave my kids to their own devices, they'll all speak their native languages all the time, and ignore me altogether. So the seating chart becomes kind of an art form. You start by letting the students sit wherever they want and proceed from there. This kid is too close to the door, and tries to escape every time you turn your back, so he has to be moved closer to the window. Fortunately, the window doesn't open enough for him to crawl out, because you know the two-story drop will not, in itself, be enough to deter him.

Then you get to the more common issue, that of the students electing to sit with absolutely no one who doesn't speak their first language. Sure, you may get a smattering of kids who don't speak the dominant language (or languages), and have no choice. Those kids, in many ways, are the luckiest. They have to either pursue speaking English or talk to themselves. There's an intrinsic motivation there you don't see elsewhere.

Then there are the tables of four in which they turn inward, have private conversations, and tune out the class completely. These become my first targets. They cannot stand. So I separate them. This is a tough process, and much protest and whining ensues. You change their seats and find them changed back the following day.

Sometimes you get lucky. You may move one kid who is intrinsically social. After a few days, that kid will make the supreme sacrifice and start speaking English with kids who are not in her language group. The kid will come and ask to move, but you leave her there and she benefits. Sometimes, though, the kid sits there like a bag of potatoes and refuses to utter word one to anyone. You watch the kid grow sadder by the day, and you're sorely tempted to dump that kid back with friends who speak the same language.

It's really very hard to watch a student suffer like that. It's especially frustrating if they student is also tuned out to the class. The choices then become watching this student miserable and failing or watching this student relatively content and failing. Sometimes there are back stories these kids bring that seem to preclude happiness, and that makes the problem even worse.

So your seating chart becomes a year-long, ever-evolving work of art, and no matter what you do it's never finished. It's natural to hang with people you find familiar. I'm pretty sure if I were in China I'd make fast friends with fellow Americans. It might make me feel safer or more secure. On the other hand, if I want to feel safe and secure, if I'm resistant to change, if I don't want to grow or learn anything new, what the hell am I doing in China?

It's quite different if I'm a teenager and my parents dragged me there (or here) kicking and screaming. Until the kicks and screams die down, I'm not making the slightest attempt toward assimilating, let alone getting to know people from other cultures. So I put up walls, and it's very hard for teachers to break through.

My job is looking for cracks in those walls, getting through as much as possible, and shooting them down completely at the earliest opportunity. It's challenging work.

Friday, December 21, 2018

If Santa Used a DOE Computer, There Would Be Many Unhappy Children

This may have been the slowest week of the year, but take heart, because next week will be the fastest. Before you can say, "Wow, I have a week off," you'll be moving your time card and saying, "Where did that week go?" People will ask how your vacation was and you'll have to tell them,"I woke up this morning and it was over."

How do these things happen? Greater minds than mine have puzzled these things out, and there are simply no good answers. But take heart, because somewhere around three today, you'll be off. I'd say off and running, but it's Friday, it's the last day before a vacation, and it's supposed to rain. So unless you live across the street from where you work, there's gonna be a slight delay between work and vacation.

I used to make fun of teachers who'd say the tech in their rooms didn't work. Yesterday I learned that I've become inseparable from technology. I should've known this would happen when I started bringing a Macbook Air with me to school every day. I was further corrupted when my supervisor placed me in a room with working tech, assuming I'd feel obliged to use it. (Alas, she was completely right about that.) But yesterday I forgot to bring it, and I felt like I'd shown up to work in my pajamas.

Yesterday I didn't need to show any presentations. We've thankfully dumped the crappy online attendance system. What I did yesterday was give a couple of tests. After doing so I needed to record the grades and had no laptop. I logged into a school computer and waited. And waited, And waited. When it finally showed me a screen, I waited some more until a few icons showed up.

I signed on to Skedula on Safari, something I do every day on my laptop. But the screen I saw showed no option to "continue login" and I was stuck. A helpful colleague said try another browser. I tried Firefox. Same thing.. Finally I used Chrome and it worked. I don't love the mouse on the school computers, and everything took a whole lot longer than I expected. Seriously, I have no idea how any teacher survives without carrying a laptop.

I guess if you just have a marking book it can be simpler than using school computers. I think, though, that with an online gradebook and decent hardware you don't really lose any time. But we're on break beginning tomorrow and there's no time to lose.

I wish you a week absent of computer problems, perhaps absent of computers. I hope you get to go somewhere wonderful, see someone wonderful, and do something wonderful.

I wish you a happy and healthy break. Don't let anyone make you feel guilty about it because you earned every single second of it. People who don't know what we do think we're on vacation all the time. While one week goes fast, I think I'd be bored by perpetual vacation. You can't just hang with social media all day.

If you're looking for me, absent flooding or storm, I'll be walking my dog along the Woodcleft Canal. What are you doing this holiday week?

Thursday, December 20, 2018

Richer Than Soil and Dumber Than Dirt

That's how I'd describe US Education Secretary Betsy DeVos. Oddly, in her zeal to prevent gun atrocity, she doesn't even consider that guns are a factor. She doesn't consider that these episodes are endemic here, and barely occur in countries where guns are carefully regulated.

Now in her defense, she bought that position fair and square. She's paid off every tinhorn GOP hack this side of the Panama Canal. Also, she's never held a real job before, so how can she be expected to know how to do this one? A lot of people don't take that into account when writing about her. However, incompetence is not always the best defense for doing a terrible job. Let's take a look at Betsy's new initiative:

The Department of Education is poised to rescind Obama-era policies that sought to ensure minority students are not unfairly disciplined in schools, an effort the Trump administration believes will alleviate school-related violence.

Now, what exactly is the alternative to ensuring "minority students are not unfairly disciplined?" To my mind, that suggests we need to start disciplining minority students unfairly. That will get right to the heart of the issue of school shootings, won't it? But, wait a minute...aren't all or most of the school shooters white? Should we perhaps discipline them unfairly? Let's look a little closer at the Trumpies' explanation:

Senior White House administration officials said that the commission heard a "recurring narrative" that teachers and students were afraid because individuals who had a history of antisocial, or sometimes violent, behavior were left unpunished or unchecked. They said rescinding this policy would address that issue.

Okay. Let's say that's true. How will unfairly disciplining minority students address that? I don't know about you, but when I get treated unfairly, it kind of pisses me off. Now sure, I don't go around shooting people when I'm angry, but as far as I know, neither do minority students. Every one of those school shooters seems to be a white guy. Perhaps their theory is that by being unfair to minority students, the white guys won't be so mad anymore. Oddly, though, in Trump's America, I see a lot more empowered white guys feeling entitled to say or do anything.

In fact, this report inspired a rebuke from the reformiest of the reformies:

In a joint statement provided to CNN on Tuesday, former Education Secretaries John King Jr. and Arne Duncan said that by rescinding the Obama-era policies, the Trump administration was "(turning) its back on our most vulnerable students." 

These two guys know quite a bit about treating minorities unfairly. Reformy John taught three whole years, and famously disregarded entire crowds of people who spoke against his hurtful and idiotic policies. Doing that catapulted him to the reformiest position in the country, the one now held by Betsy DeVos. And Arne, who never taught at allmfamously praised the horrendous disaster. Sure people died, Sure people left their homes and never came back. Sure it cost taxpayers a hundred billion dollars. But Arne said it was the best thing to ever happen to New Orleans education, because the privatized the whole city, and Arne's rich pals got even richer.

Sure, Betsy DeVos is even worse than Arne or Reformy John, but they set the stage to allow her to take reforminess to a new level. If Arne and Reformy John were great for having little or no teaching experience, Betsy is better because she has no experience whatsoever.

You know what I would do if I were Education Secretary? I would lobby to make the assault weapons used in school shootings illegal. I would buy back AR-15s and their ilk from Americans and establish strict penalties for any non-military who owned them. On the other hand, I haven't taken millions from the NRA. Now don't get me wrong. I'd be happy to take millions from them. A world where I have more millions and they have fewer would look fine to me. I'd donate the millions to anti-NRA groups, and try to send NRA back to the primordial sludge where it belongs.

If we ever want to stop the gun violence, we're gonna have to stop the guns, and we're also gonna have to stop each and every NRA-owned politician. We're also gonna have to send Betsy back to Michigan. From there they can equip one of her homes with rocket fuel and send her to the moon.

Apologies in advance to the moon.

Wednesday, December 19, 2018

Student Perception Survey 2018

About a week ago I got the results of our last "Student Perception Survey," the one we gave a year ago. I'm not exactly sure how that was supposed to help us. given the results came from students we don't even see anymore. We did, however, go through the steps of this absurd exercise once again this year, so once again I'm sharing my impression of what it looked like.

1. How much do you hate this class?

a. I hate it.   b. I really hate it   c. I hate it to the moon and back.

2. How much does this teacher care whether you learn the material?

a. just teaches it   b. stays an hour after class to explain   c. comes to my home to explain

3. How bored are you in this class?

a. normal   b. abnormal   c. Oh my gosh, get me out of here!

4. How much time does the teacher spend decorating the classroom?

a only a few hours a week   b. 50 hours a week   c. 200 hours a week

5. How often does this teacher make you explain your answers?

a. all the time, the bastard  b. all the time, the SOB  c. all the time, the reptilian crud face

6. How unfair are the rules for this class?

a. fairly unfair   b. very unfair  c. extremely unfair

7. How much does this teacher give a crap how well you do?

a. one crap   b. two craps  c. not even a crap

8. How much does the teacher's failure to control the class bother you?

a. a little   b. a lot  c. The teacher is a snowflake.

9. How often do you stare at the clock and pray it will move?

a. ten times a period   b. a hundred times a period  c. all period

10. How little does this teacher care how you do?

a. very little  b. not at all  c. Teacher actively works to make me fail.

11. How much does your teacher hate teaching?

a. a lot   b. as much as I hate the class   c. even more than I hate the class

12. When class finally ends, how much time do you spend regretting every minute you wasted?

a. an hour   b. endless hours   c. all the time

13. When you give up because the class is hopelessly incomprehensible, how much time does the teacher spend ridiculing you?

a. the whole period   b. Teacher stays after class to ridicule me more  c. Teacher follows me home.

14. How much does this teacher know about the topic of the class?

a. nothing   b. less than nothing  c. Class has no particular topic.

15.How many times per period does this class make you wish to commit an unnatural act?

a. many times  b. a lot  c. all the time

16. Does this teacher come over your house and cook Thanksgiving Dinner?

a. Never, the bastard   b. Sometimes, the bastard   c. Always, the bastard

17. How often does this teacher make cruel remarks for no reason?

a. sometimes   b. usually   c. always

18. How disrespectful is this teacher?

a. pretty much so   b. very much so   c. burning this teacher in effigy later today

19. How much does this teacher fail to control the class?

a. as much as other teachers  b. more than other teachers  c. It's psychedelic pandemonium.

20. How much of your time does this teacher waste?

a. the entire period   b. I waste time thinking about it after class as well. c. my entire life

21. How insincere is this teacher when asking how you are?

a. very   b. totally   c. 100%

22. How out of touch is this teacher?

a. very   b. totally   c. 100%

23. You know by now we want you to say the teacher sucks. Does the teacher suck?

a. Yes.   b. certainly   c. Of course.

24. If you walked into class upset, how little would the teacher care?

a. very little   b. not at all   c. Teacher would make it worse on purpose.

25. How poorly does the teacher answer your questions?

a. very poorly   b. just looks into space and says nothing   c. shoots me into space and says nothing

26. How alienated are you from this teacher?

a. very   b. totally   c. 100%

27. Overall, how much do you hate this class and this teacher?

a. I hate it.   b. I really hate it   c. I hate it to the moon and back.

Monday, December 17, 2018

UFT Executive Board December 17th, 2018 OT/ PT Chapter Wants an Improved Contract

6 PM—Secretary Howard Schoor welcomes us.

Four speakers—

Dave Jensen—Per-diem subs—speaking on part of colleague. Many per-diem have had deductions for union, expecting representation or due process. Subs have few or none due process rights. Paraprofessionals have been given that right. Article 42 says the union and DOE will develop best practices, but they feel that is not enough. They shoulder responsibility, teach 4 in a row, have no lesson plans and are subject to being placed on DNU lists that preclude working. Several colleagues have suffered this treatment. Sub-central disinterested, with too much authority. One person, not collaborative, not promoting best practices. Demand more transparent referee. Asks why as due-paying members subs did not participate in negotiation.

Judith Lowell—Physical Therapist, Delegate to OT/ PT chapter. OT/ PT for fair contract member. Glad DA passed resolution in support. Still negotiating, appreciate DA’s support. Resolution puzzling because it had something about education OT/ PT to stay with union. Some have been critical out of frustration. Our group supports unionism and UFT. We are strong union members, believe in UFT, want to work with leadership and membership.

Melissa Willams—OT in district 6. Door-knocker for UFT. Working on last non-member. Concerned that union doesn’t have capacity to tolerate grassroots organizing. We got email from our Exec. Board, saying, “Our contract has not been ratified so this has left us vulnerable to outside forces.” We are concerned with issues that affect other chapters as well. We think they mean the socialist party by outside forces. We don’t want divisive rhetoric or red-baiting. We will not tolerate it. We aim for unity, staying with UFT. Anytime we hear negativity we say we’re sticking with union. We would like pay parity. Would like to use model of paid parental leave. We need a big tent, socialists, libertarians, and democrats, GOP and everyone. Hands out buttons and asks we pledge to wear them.

Rachel Fineson
—Thanks DA for passing resolution. Loves job but has to work two others. 35 of 50 in room I was in also worked multiple jobs. What is UFT plan for renegotiating contract?

Minutes—approved

President’s Report—Michael Mulgrew—Governor outlined plans for legislative session. Thinks we have to fix inequity in school funding, specifically on capital plans, funding based on need, happy to see that. rest of agenda progressive, women’s rights, cash bail, overall quite positive. Rumors Cathy Nolan will no longer chair ed. committee. Hearing diBenedetto, from Bronx, UFT member. We’ll wait and see. Nolan may be deputy speaker. Pay raise issue sucking up all the oxygen, but we need to get budget done.

Thanks Karen Alford and all who worked on homeless coalition event. Best event we do all year.

Wishes us happy holiday and happy new year. Thanks us for our time, for going above and beyond. We are moving forward—will be state legislative breakfast here tomorrow. Lots of them don’t know what we do, think it’s “standard union stuff.”

Enemies of union are gearing up. Take time and relax. It gives me comfort to know this leadership is in place.

LeRoy Barr—Public Advocate forums, first last Thursday in Queens. Great turnout. Members can question all candidates. Tomorrow meeting here. Next EB January 7, DA 16th, happy holidays.

Mike Schirtzer—Where are we on OT/ PT contract? Any progress? And we’re still hearing that principals and admin are mandating lesson plans. Can we reiterate to reinforce idea that plans are not to benefit admin.

Schoor—We have reached out to labor relations on OT/ PT. Not yet responded. Meeting with chapter on demands and changes. We will be ready when they are. No guarantee when they will come to table. We will work on it.

Lesson plans—That was in principal’s weekly. Thanks Debbie Poulos. We wanted prep periods and lesson planning explained and they did so.


Arthur Goldstein—It looks like the Senate will vote to uncouple test scores from teacher ratings. This will be different for high school teachers because we were not affected by the Regents moratorium. If the Senate does vote to uncouple test scores, what will happen in high schools? What will take the place of our current MOSL?

Schoor—Doesn’t know.

Evelyn de Jesus—Meeting now. Have an assessment committee looking at how they will move agenda. We’re working on it.

Paul Egan—Legislation would decouple teacher evaluation from student test scores. Hopeful that can be done earlier rather than later. Not sure if it includes Regents.

Janella Hinds—Goal is to ensure all divisions are covered. We expect it will be all test scores decoupled from MOSL.

Melody Cooper—non-board member--Schoor allows her to speak--Midwood elementary teacher—Asks about adverse ratings for untenured teachers. Concerned with background check and due process regarding that.

Schoor—Untenured teachers don’t have same rights. Can be discontinued. Try to get them through probationary period. City has right to do pre-employment testing. We negotiated that when they are hired, they can test them later, in case they are hired mid-year.

Reports from districts

Eliu Lara—Last Monday Bronx HS district had superintendents forum. Members were told what they needed for tenure.

Mike Schirtzer—A longtime Murrow music teacher and conductor from HS passed. Asks moment of silence.

Shout out to Infotech HS in Queens. Had Thanksgiving lunch. UFT raised 1K and hosted lunch for underprivileged kids. Doing holiday toy drive for homeless.

Priscilla Castro—Dec. 6, Meet DR in Brooklyn. Will be one in Manhattan for D75.

Legislative report—Paul Egan—Chelsea—great win. Eagles had great win and terrible loss. Blames referees. DOE legal calling plays.
Forum Thursday in Queens. Race getting ridiculous. 16 candidates now running. Actual number may be up to 23. Not difficult to get on ballot. If 23 people make it on, I would hate to see what ballot looks like. How will Board of Elections get this right?

Jumaane Williams, Michael Blake did well. Everyone was late. Tomorrow here on 19th floor. Feel free to come. 4 to 7 PM. Final will be January 10th in Brooklyn. Will be all candidates on stage. Mulgrew will MC. Leticia James resigns January 1st. Expect election 2/26

Tom Murphy
—wants Medicare to negotiate drug prices. When Obamacare was passed was bundle of compromises. VA negotiates prices but Medicare forbidden. NY Dems were in thrall of pharma and voted for this. Hope to place this before new Congress, though Senate and President may not support it. Maybe bipartisan bill can pass, but if not, still has intrinsic value.

Passes

Motion to adjourn


Passes 6:39