Friday, December 21, 2007

State Fails City Schools That Received "A's" and "B's" On Kleinberg Report Cards

The NY Daily News reports this morning that the state is failing 61 high-poverty and 4 low-poverty city elementary and middle schools.

The state hasn't released the list of failing city high schools yet. That list will come next year.

When the failing high schools are added to the failing elementary and middle schools, the total is expected to outnumber the 421 city schools listed as failing by the state last year (out of 1,348 evaluated schools.)

To be fair, the state did expand the testing criteria that was used for judging schools and offered that as an excuse for why more city schools were added to the failing list this year.

Nonetheless, here is how the Daily News characterized the story:

The report is a sting to Bloomberg and Schools Chancellor Joel Klein, who have trumpeted improvements in test scores and graduation rates as proof that their sweeping school reforms are working.

Many of the schools the state judged to be failing did well on the city's new and controversial school grading system.

Of the 65 schools added to the list, nine earned an A from the city, 21 earned B's and only four earned an F.

Anybody notice a trend when it comes to these statistics?

When Bloomberg and Klein control the lists, the stats, the report cards and/or the testing methodologies, the city does wonderfully and Bloomberg's education reforms are helping kids make progress.

Yet when the state judges the same schools that Bloomberg and Klein handed "A's" and "B's" to, many of them are listed as failing.

And when the feds released the NAEP tests, the results show the city has made little-to-no progress on test scores since Bloomberg took office (as opposed to the state tests which show "great progress" for city students according to Bloomberg and Klein.)

And then there are the graduation rate accounting methods Bloomberg and Klein use - simply don't count the kids who don't graduate and the city graduation rates skyrocket!

Hmmm- looks like Bloomberg and Klein brought their own Houston Miracle to New York City.
blog comments powered by Disqus